Scrimshire Family Roots: English and Scottish

Family roots, English, and Scottish

To understand the family roots back to England and Scotland we have to focus on Joyce Scrimshire (Margaret Scrimshire, born in S.C. around 1787), Joyce was born about 1520 in the liberty of Norbury and Darlaston, we must begin not with a date but with a word. The name she carries into Darlaston Hall in 1536 is older than either manor.

Scrimshire is not English in its root. The dictionaries trace it to Old French eskirmir — “to skirmish, to fence” — and to escarmouche, a skirmish. The earliest form in Britain is Scrimgeour, bearer of the sword for the King of Scots, later a surname for a fencer, a champion, a man who taught the art of defence. By the time it reaches Staffordshire it has settled into Skrymsher, Skrimshire, Scrimshire.

“Skrymsher was the name of an old Staffordshire family that owned the manor of Norbury from the 16th to the 18th century.”

FOREBEARS, SURNAME DISTRIBUTION AND ORIGIN

The Norbury line was substantial enough to be assessed for the realm’s defence. When the call went out against the Spanish Armada in 1588, the family contributed £25 each — a considerable sum, placing them among the county’s modest gentry rather than mere yeomen. It is a measure of standing, not wealth, that survives in the Exchequer rolls.

Two centuries later the name is still found as freeholders at North Muskham — recorded as North Muscombe — and at Newark-on-Trent, Nottinghamshire, keeping to the Trent valley that links Norbury to the east. The Staffordshire Scrimshires, however, remain fixed: Norbury Manor is theirs from the 1500s until the 1700s, a quiet, long tenure that straddles the Tudors and Stuarts.

Norbury Manor

Norbury is not large. A manor house, a church of St. Peter, a moat that still holds water in winter. The Scrimshires of Norbury — Skrimshire in the parish register — held it as lords for two hundred years. Their pedigree, imperfect as all Tudor pedigrees are, begins with Thomas Skrimshire of Norbury and his wife Mary Swineshead.

Their daughter Elizabeth was born about 1510, when Henry VIII was still a young king newly married to Katherine. She is the elder sister in a household where land, not court, is the preoccupation. Ten years later — about 1520 — another daughter, Joyce, is born. The registers give her place as both Norbury and Darlaston, a confusion that tells its own truth: the family held interests in both, and a child might be baptised where the mother was lying in.

This is Joyce’s family. Not a great family, but an old one, with a manor and a name that meant someone who knew how to stand and hold a line.

The 1536 Marriage

PARISH NOTE • DARLASTON, STONE

GROOM

Sir Robert Collier (Colyer / Collyer)

Born 1515 — some pedigrees say in France whilst his father traded wool, others simply at Stone. Son of James Colyer, lord of Darlaston by purchase.

BRIDE

Joyce Scrimshire

Daughter of Scrimshire of Norbury. Born c.1520 Norbury / Darlaston. Second generation of Norbury gentry.

Date: 1536

Place: Darlaston, Stone, Staffordshire

Henry VIII’s 27th regnal year — the year of the Dissolution

They marry in the same year the monasteries begin to fall. It is not a love match in the modern sense, nor is it merely property. Robert, twenty-one, needs a wife from a family with older standing than his own; Joyce, sixteen, brings the Scrimshire name and a link to Norbury Manor. The hall at Darlaston becomes her home for seventeen years.

Joyce dies in 1553, the year Edward VI dies and Mary comes to the throne. She is about thirty-three. After her death, Robert marries secondly Agnes Manwaring Venables — a Cheshire alliance, a widow’s jointure, a sign that Darlaston now looks outward.

Lord of the Manor

In 1549, thirteen years after his marriage to Joyce, Robert Collyer of Darlaston is named Lord of the Manor of Stone and receives a market licence for the town of Stone. It is a small thing in national history, a large thing in Staffordshire. Stone had had a market since the Augustinian priory, but now the right is confirmed in the hands of a lay lord — Robert — whose father bought the land from monks.

We must imagine Robert in these years: a man who has buried his first wife, who holds two manors by lease and freehold, who secures a market and then arms. He will live into Elizabeth’s reign, long enough to see his son Thurston marry. Joyce’s Scrimshire name fades from the hall’s deeds, but it remains in the children’s blood — and in the Norbury connection that persists in later litigation.

Life is short, seasonal, local. A woman like Joyce Scrimshire would rarely travel more than ten miles from home. Her year is marked by Lady Day rents, Michaelmas accounting, the birth and death of children. She would know the Swinesheads, the Whalleys, the Jervises who will one day buy her home. She would not know London.

This chapter closes in 1553, with Joyce’s death. Her eldest son James is a young man; her third son Thurston is eleven. The manor years — 1515 to 1553 — are the span of one Tudor generation: from Henry VIII’s youth to Edward’s death, from abbey lease to armigerous gentry. It is a complete story in itself, before the next century carries the Scrimshires to Haddenham and, much later, to a football field in 2000. Real football, a local footballer named Andrew ‘scrimmy’ Scrimshire. 

One of these players opened the scoring, as the first team’s impressive youngster Will Wallace capitalised on a Charlton defensive error to pounce on a loose ball and put Haddenham one-nil in front. Andrew ‘Scrimmy’ Scrimshire then put Haddenham two up before half time with a hard driven shot, which was his first goal in his three years at the club.

Here’s an overview of my focus on Joyce Scrimshire 

Sir Robert COLLIER was born in 1515 in France. He died in 1587 in France. A Coat of Arms was conceded to Robert Collier of Darleston by letter paten in 1538 Parents: James COLLIERand Isabella LEVERSOM.

He was married to Joyce SCRIMSHIRE in 1536 in Darlaston By Stone, Staffordshire, England. Children were: James COLLIER of Darlington , Margaret COLYER, Thurston COLLIER, Richard COLYER, Isabella COLYER, Cecilia COLYER, Christopher COLLIER.

And in the middle of all that here is this extract which is explained below  

Chesterfield, Derbyshire Extract from Lysons’ Topographical and Historical Account of Derbyshire, 1817 (Magna Britannia Vol 5)

In the year 1678 Charles Scrimshire, Esq., of Norbury in Staffordshire, (afterwards Sir Charles), built an alms-house for six poor women, pursuant to the will of George Taylor, Esq., of Durant-hall, who died in 1668, having bequeathed a sum of money for that purpose, and a rent-charge of 16 pounds per annum for the endowment. The pensioners were to have 38s 4d each monthly, coals, and a gown once in two years. Mr. Francis Moore, in 1715, gave a small yearly benefaction to the poor in Taylor’s hospital. The corporation are trustees.

Here is the full story of that extract:

Where it fits: 1668-1678, The Next Generation at Norbury

I left the Scrimshires at Norbury in 1553 when Joyce died. By 1678 they are still Lords of Norbury, but now wealthy enough to build in Derbyshire.

“In the year 1678 Charles Scrimshire, Esq., of Norbury in Staffordshire, (afterwards Sir Charles), built an alms-house for six poor women, pursuant to the will of George Taylor, Esq., of Durant-hall, who died in 1668…”

Full context from Lysons’ Magna Britannia Vol 5, 1817 and Tapton history:

•  George Taylor, Esq., of Durant Hall — Durant Hall is Tapton Hall, Chesterfield, Derbyshire. He died in 1668 and left instructions in his will for alms-houses to be founded.

•  Charles Scrimshire Esq. of Norbury, Staffordshire — He was Taylor’s son-in-law. He married Esther Taylor, George Taylor’s daughter and sole heiress. 

•  1678 Build — Pursuant to the will, Charles built 6 alms-houses in Salter Gate, Chesterfield — as the inscription in the centre still attests. He endowed them with a rent-charge of £16 per annum. The pensioners were to have 38s 4d each monthly, coals, and a gown once in two years.

•  Afterwards Sir Charles — He was knighted, and later became Sheriff of Derbyshire in 1698.

This is the same Scrimshire family defined in the surname histories as: “Skrymsher was the name of an old Staffordshire family that owned the manor of Norbury in that county from the 16th to the 18th century” — the family that contributed £25 apiece against the Spanish Armada in 1588.

An overview fits as follows: 

1515-1553 Darlaston: Joyce Scrimshire of Norbury marries Robert Collier — wool trader, Lord of Darlaston.

1657-1670 London: William Scrimshire, haberdasher, leases 6B Bow Lane, burnt out in Great Fire, rebuilds under Fire Court.

1678 Chesterfield: Charles Scrimshire Esq. of Norbury, heir to Durant Hall via marriage to Esther Taylor, builds the Taylor alms-houses in Salter Gate for six poor women — showing the family still had manorial wealth and was acting as trustees for the corporation.

Then you jump 300 some years to:

2000s Haddenham: Andrew ‘Scrimmy’ Scrimshire puts Haddenham two up with a hard-driven shot, first goal in three years.

Joyce fits perfectly under the heading ‘ the English/Scottish name’.

She’s the English side of that Anglo-Scottish name.

Here is where she sits:

The England/Scottland name heading quoted in this post (add link) covers two parallel families with the same root:

“Scrimshire is an Anglo-Scottish occupational surname from Old French eskermir, ‘to fence’…”

•  Scottish line: Scrimgeour, Scrymegour — hereditary standard-bearers of Scotland. Sir Alexander Schyrmeschur lands in Forfar 1298, Constable of Dundee, Earl of Dundee 1660, etc.

•  English line: Skrymsher / Skrimshire — The text even says: “A separate old Staffordshire gentry family, Skrymsher / Skrimshire of Norbury, owned manors from the 1500s into the 1700s.”

Joyce IS that Staffordshire gentry family.

•  Joyce Scrimshire ±1520-1553 — daughter of Scrimshire of Norbury, as WikiTree and the genealogy trees list her.

•  Born in Norbury, Derbyshire / Staffordshire border area — Norbury is the manor that family owned from the 16th to 18th century.

•  Marries in 1536 at Darlaston by Stone, Staffordshire, to Robert Collier — exactly the manor-owning network described.

So the paragraph is accurate when it says:

•  Early English examples William Lescermissur 1180, Symon Leskirmisur 1221, Richer le Schirmissur 1154 — that’s the medieval root.

•  Scottish Scrymegours held the standard-bearer office — that’s the Scottish branch.

•  Staffordshire Skrymsher of Norbury — that’s Joyce’s direct family.

It has not been proved on paper as the direct parent of the Virginia–Georgia farmers… John Scrimshire (John Brown Scrimshire), born about 1720 in England and married to Ann Lyons, is the colonial ancestor…”

I’m still unable to prove by a paper trail from Joyce 1520 to John Brown Scrimshire 1720 to the Georgia farmers.

However for sure Joyce is my anchor for the English gentry line:

“Joyce Scrimshire (c.1520-1553), daughter of the Skrymsher family who owned the manor of Norbury in Staffordshire from the 1500s into the 1700s, represents the old Staffordshire gentry branch of a name that is Anglo-Scottish in origin — from Old French eskermir, to fence — with one branch becoming hereditary standard-bearers in Scotland, and the other, our branch, holding manors in Staffordshire.”

My GGG’grandmother was Margaret Scrimshire, born in S.C. around 1787. She was of English descent. According to information in a letter written by a daughter-in-law of hers before 1900, Margaret had three brothers who married into the Cherokee tribe. One of the brothers, George, was said to have married a full-blood; and a daughter of his married “Bushy Head”, late chief of the Cherokees.

Margaret Emily Scrimshire born on 23 Aug either 1873 or 1875. Her mother died when she was a baby, approx. 3 months old when their house caught on fire. She took Margaret Emily outside, laid her down and went back in the house when it caved in on her.

In the reign of Edward VI, the Church Goods Commissioners recorded four bells in the steeple, and various items of plate.

Ten people were presented as Popish recusants between 1604 and 1628. The Protestation returns of 1641/2 include Gregory Henson, ‘recusant’. The Return gives the names of 167 men over the age of 18, including Robert Kinder, the Rector, and Anthony Sommersby, curate. Ten individuals shared the surname Scrimshire. Harold Scrimshire was constable, and Thomas Scrimshire was churchwarden. The Scrimshaws owned land in Cotgrave. Members of the family had previously been rector, and several monumental stones commemorating their lives can be found in the churchyard. Subsequently the name appeared as Scrimshaw.

St. Mary le Bow Lane

The property was burnt in the Great Fire and in February 1668 John Ince sold his one-third share of a plot, formerly 3 messuages and earlier one great messuage called the Crown, to Thomas Moffett, citizen and grocer, for £80. Moffatt then or earlier acquired the remaining two-thirds interest, and in May 1668, with his wife Katharine, sold the whole toft, to Arthur Bettesworth of London, merchant, for £310. Two foundation surveys were made for Bettsworth in Bow Lane in 1668. One, in April, was for 2 foundations, evidently the front part of the property only, the remaining part of the plot, of irregular shape, was surveyed in September. In 1669 Mr. Scrimshire, of 6B, complained about Bettsworth’s rebuilding, and part of the property was viewed. The two parties had adjoining yards, formerly divided by a fence wall belonging to Betsworth. There had been a calendar-house, covered with a shed one storey high, over which the back part of his fore-building used to receive light. There had been a building 3 or 4 yards South of the fence wall, but in rebuilding Betsworth had extended this to the boundary, building over the site of the calendar-house and replacing the fence with a party wall, through which he had made several lights into Scrimshire’s yard. This new building had greatly darkened Scrimshire’s yard. (Footnote)   From: British History Online Source: St. Mary le Bow 104/6. Historical gazetteer of London before the Great Fire, Keene, D.J.; Harding, Vanessa. (1987).

In 1657 Lawrence March, esquire, owned 6B and leased a part of it, measuring 40 ft. towards Bow Lane and 41 ft. in depth, to William Scrimshire, haberdasher, for 11 1/4 years. Despite the reference to Bow Lane, this was evidently the westernmost part of the property. In 1659 Marsh leased the middle part of the property, to William Coddington for 21 years at £20. 4s. rent. In 1664 he leased the easternmost part, along the Bow Lane frontage by 50 ft. to Thomas Allen, barber-surgeon, for 21 years at £25 p.a.  The occupants of 6B in 1661 appear to have been William Scrimshire, together with Thomas Dawson, William Doeman, and James Harris, who may have been Scrimshire’s partners or associates, and whose names were bracketed with his in the assessment list, and William Coddington and Thomas Allen. By his will of 1665 Lawrence Marsh left a moiety of his messuages to his wife Elizabeth for life, and the other moiety and the remainder of the first to his son Lawrence in tail. Thomas Allen, citizen and barber- surgeon, died in 1665 or January 1666, leaving his lands and houses to his wife Mary. Early in 1666 William Coddington senior occupied a house with 7 hearths on the W. side of Bow Lane, and Caleb Nicholas, possibly Allen’s successor, an adjacent house also with 7 hearths. Scrimshire does not appear to be listed in the Hearth Tax for that year, but he and Dawson, noted as partners, William Cottington and Thomas Nicholls were listed among those with houses in St. Mary le Bow precinct, Cordwainer ward, destroyed in the Great Fire.

By 1668 Scrimshire had acquired the leases of all 3 parts. In December 1668 the Fire Court confirmed his agreement with Elizabeth Marsh, widow, acting as guardian for her sons Lawrence, James, John, and William, by which he agreed to rebuild, in return for an extension of all 3 leases by 40 years, and a reduction of the rents to £12. 10s., £6. 5s., and £6. 5s., payable from 1669. Lawrence Marsh was to make a lease or leases for the remainder of the extended term when he came of age. One foundation, the easternmost, was surveyed for William Scrimshaw or Scrimsheer in March 1669. The middle part of the property does not seem to have been surveyed, was shown on the survey for Scrimshire. The westernmost part of the property, leased to Scrimshire in 1657, was surveyed for him in 1670.  From: British History Online Source: St. Mary le Bow 104/6. Historical gazetteer of London before the Great Fire, Keene, D.J.; Harding, Vanessa. (1987).

The English/Scottish name

Scrimshire is an Anglo-Scottish occupational surname from Old French eskermir, “to fence” or fight hand to hand. Middle English turned that into skrymsher. A fencing master was a respectable medieval trade, though London at times banned fencing schools as a public nuisance. Recorded spellings include Scrimgeour, Scriminger, Scrymegour, Scrimger, Skrimshire, Scrimshaw, Schrimshire, and Schrimsher.

Early English examples include William Lescermissur of Suffolk (1180) and Symon Leskirmisur of Essex (1221). The Scottish Scrymegour family held the hereditary office of standard-bearer of Scotland for centuries. Sir Alexander Schyrmeschur received lands in Forfar in 1298 and later became Constable of Dundee Castle. John Scrymgeour was created Earl of Dundee in 1660. The first recorded spelling commonly cited is Richer le Schirmissur, 1154, in the Danelaw documents for Lincolnshire.

A separate old Staffordshire gentry family, Skrymsher / Skrimshire of Norbury, owned manors from the 1500s into the 1700s. That English gentry line is real, but it has not been proved on paper as the direct parent of the Virginia–Georgia farmers. What can be said safely is that the American name is English in origin, and that a John Scrimshire (often styled John Brown Scrimshire), born about 1720 in England and married to Ann Lyons (often listed as Welsh), is the colonial ancestor most compiled trees place behind the southern United States family.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More Articles & Posts